August 21, 2016

Without values the academy risks anarchy...

"...This ‘me first’ approach is also not helped by academia’s demanding working conditions. In labs an entrenched hierarchy prevails which determines whose agenda dominates the work flow and whose name takes precedence on publications, whilst for more independent researchers, long hours spent in isolation in libraries or archives can take its toll on basic social capabilities and interactions.

While the realities of the academic environment do not excuse individuals from displaying discriminatory or anti-social behaviour towards others, they go some way to explaining why some academics do not see anything untoward about their own uncouth conduct, or why they are attuned to thinking about themselves and their own gain first. When it comes down to it, the system in which they work has come to facilitate narcissistic and egotistical behaviour, if not even demand it.

In this context, putting an emphasis back on the original values of a university could do much to quell the rise of bullying and discrimination. Allowing the market-driven model to dominate the higher education sector for so long has only created a vacuum of values in the way the academic system operates, removing a university’s in-built system of moral checks and balances that might otherwise serve to keep its staff on the straight and narrow.

The ivory tower has lost sight of its primary, foundational function – namely, to nurture the flourishing of the human spirit for the benefit of wider society. When community values were at the core of the academy, its outputs were beneficial to civil society and its workforce adhered to the principles of partnership, equality and fairness. With these values now replaced by the pursuit of profit and fame, is it any wonder that the new academic arena has become a breeding ground for bullies?

If the ivory tower is to retain its image of an idyllic place to work, then, it would not go far wrong in revisiting the common and societal-based values that once shaped its past. Without these values, the academy has no value to anything other than itself. And without these values, the academy may as well prepare for anarchy now..."

Dr Diana Beech is a research consultant at the Research Information Network and a research associate at St Edmund’s College, Cambridge, where she currently manages a project exploring the role and relevance of values to contemporary European research policy. Beech is also an active member of the EURAXESS ‘Voice of the Researchers’ network, providing researchers with a channel to influence policy in the European Research Area.


Anonymous said...

personally i think academia begets an extraordinary egotism

Anonymous said...

Most academics, once they get their doctorates and receive tenure, feel themselves to be like Superman with the added ability to tap dance on water. This sense of invulnerability and omnipotence permeates just about everything they do. They are *never* wrong--they have Ph. D.s and, therefore, are experts. (A good example of this is the on-going "climate change" nonsense. Never have so many seemingly educated people peddled so much twaddle and tried to make it seem credible.)

They also have a sense of permanent entitlement simply by being educated, rarely having done anything useful or otherwise tangible with that schooling. The tenure system only encourages and rewards that.

The professors I had the most respect for, both while I was an undergrad and, later, studying for my advanced degrees, were those who not only had the formal qualifications but supplemented that by actual field experience. One could believe what they said as they had both theoretical and practical knowledge. If they behaved as if they were better than everyone else, it's because they were and earned that right.

Sadly, during grad studies, there weren't very many of them.

Max Casu said...

Dear Pierre,

I would like to post my story on your blog but I cannot find any link in order to do so. I know others posted their stories on your blog. I have already opened a blog about my story, that has to be completed, you can check it and have an idea of the atrocity I have received from the University of Leicester. The link is here
you can contact me at the following e-mail
I hope to hear from you soon....